A quarter of a century ago, on November 12, 1992, members of the Church of England’s General Synod gathered to debate women priests. Five-and-a-half hours later, a measure approving female ordination passed by just two votes. Supporters outside Church House, Westminster, cheered. Opponents looked stony-faced. “In the end, the pragmatists won,” concluded a Guardian leader published shortly afterwards.
A major shift in English Christianity was now underway. Even though no serving bishop would be asked to ordain women priests or to appoint them in his diocese, more than 1,000 traditionally minded clerics were expected to leave the Cof E. They would be replaced by an estimated 1,400 women deacons who were waiting to be ordained priests. The Catholic Church braced itself for a wave of Anglican clergy, while Catholic supporters of women priests turned up the volume.
The synod vote was not a sudden development. Anglicans had discussed women priests since at least 1920, when there was an attempt to place it on the Lambeth Conference agenda. In 1975, the General Synod passed a motion saying it had “no fundamental objections”. In 1988, three years after it had approved women deacons, the synod backed draft legislation on female priests. It took four more gruelling years to pass. Even then, the Church of England didn’t immediately introduce female clergy. Campaigners had to wait until March 12, 1994, when 32 women were ordained in Bristol Cathedral. Two months later, Pope John Paul II signed a short apostolic letter ruling out female ordination. “This judgment,” he wrote, “is to be definitively held by all the Church’s faithful.” Ordinatio Sacerdotalis failed to convince Catholic advocates of women priests. But it sucked the energy out of a debate that threatened to polarise Catholics as it had Anglicans.
The then Archbishop of Canterbury, George Carey, did not hide his dismay at the pope’s intervention. In a private audience the following year, Carey reportedly pressed John Paul II on why he had ruled out women priests. “Anthropology!” was the pope’s terse reply. In other words, it was God’s plan that the priesthood should be reserved to men and no vote could change that.
Ultimately, the Catholic Church received almost 400 former CofE clergy. Some, such as Bishop Alan Hopes of East Anglia, rose to prominence. Others served quietly in Catholic parishes, struggling to support young families.
Others still remained, hoping that they could uphold Catholic traditions within the Church of England. In 2009, Benedict XVI invited them instead to uphold Anglican traditions within the Catholic Church. In his apostolic constitution Anglicanorum Coetibus, he urged groups of Anglicans who remained attached to their heritage to join an ordinariate within the Catholic Church. The Church of England, meanwhile, pressed on inevitably towards women bishops. In 2015, Libby Lane became the first when she was ordained Bishop of Stockport.
How to continue reading…
This article appears in the Catholic Herald magazine - to read it in full subscribe to our digital edition from just 30p a week
The Catholic Herald is your essential weekly guide to the Catholic world; latest news, incisive opinion, expert analysis and spiritual reflection